Doug Buenz
Real Estate Broker
Alain Pinel Realtors
(925) 463-2000
I am a local Real Estate Broker with
Alain Pinel Realtors serving the
Pleasanton and the Tri-Valley
area. I am an avid watcher of the
local real estate market, as well as
cultural and political events.
But that is what I do, not who I am... » read more
Real Estate Q & A
Unreasonable buyers asking for more money from Seller
I entered into a contract to sell my house a couple of weeks ago. Because the market is slow, I ended up taking a lot less for my house than I was planning on. Now the buyers have had inspections, and they want me to credit them $3500 for repairs, most of which are complete B.S. I am really mad about this. Should I tell them to take a hike? Fred W.
Fred, take a deep breath and relax. In some ways this market can be called "Revenge of the Buyers". Remember 4 or 5 years ago when Sellers told buyers things like "take it or leave it" or "don't ask for anything to be fixed... we have 2 other buyers who want it". Now the tables have turned. Don't get hung up on the details of what the buyer wants. Some may be legit, and some might be categorized as outright extortion. But so what. If you want to sell you house, swallow hard and sign it. If you think you can do better in this market, tell them no. It is really that simple. But tread carefully, because working with buyers today is a little like trying to feed a squirrel. They don't really trust you, they are skittish, and at the first sign of trouble they go scampering for the woods. If you refuse the $3500, it could end up costing you $5000, $10,000, or even $20,000 more to get the next buyer in contract.
Stubborn Seller Won't Move Out?
I am buying a house in Pleasanton, and the contract is signed and the escrow is getting ready to close, and the seller decides he does not want to move out at close of escrow, but wants a week after close to move out. When we express the fact that this will not work for us, he threatens to cancel the contract. Can he do this? Ben in Pleasanton
Ben, I have good news and not so good news. The good news is that no, the seller can not unilaterally cancel a ratified contract just because he doesn't get his way. If all contingencies are removed and you are coming down to the wire, the seller can't arbitrarily start changing the terms. And he certainly can not cancel a contract. Real estate contracts are bilateral. they require the agreement of both the buyer and seller. If he attempted to cancel the contract, you could likely tie up his property so he could not sell it to someone else, and take him to court to force him to sell to you under the terms of the contract. That is the good news. The not so good news is that this course of action is time consuming, emotionally draining, and costly. If the seller becomes difficult to deal with, try to relax and work around him if you really want the house. You can always take him to small claims court after the close to recoup any out of pocket expenses you incur. Unfortunately, there is virtually no protection in a contract for an obstinant seller. You can either put up with him as best you can, and then seek renumeration in small claims court, or threaten him back, but it is difficult if not impossible to physically force the seller out of the premises. As always, consult an attorney about the specifics of your case.
Confusion on Commission Agreement?
Doug, my friend listed her house with an agent with the understanding that if one of her friends (named specifically) buys her property, the agent would be compensated at 4% commission. So one of her friends has made an offer. When the agent sent my friend the estimated pay out from the transaction, the agent put in her commission as 6%. Her explanation is that the original deal was only good until she listed the house in MLS. Is this ethical? Or legal? Or standard practice? Ginny C.
Ginny, that is a great question. As is often the case, the devil is in the details. Any agreement involving the sale or transfer or brokerage of real estate in California must be in writing to be enforceable. So if there was no written clause regarding the friend, then your friends are out of luck. So is it legal? I think a better question is the agent legally entitled to the 6%. Based on what you have described, the answer is yes, since there obviously is no written agreement regarding this situation. Is this ethical? I always have a problem with any party that does not honor the spirit of an agreement, even if the details are not specifically spelled out. But keep in mind that neither you nor I heard what was actually said. Again, this is why all agreements dealing with real estate must be in writing. I this standard practice? Again, I am not sure what you are referring to, but if there is an exception or exclusion to the commission agreement for one party, there normally is a time limit during which the party must act. Whether or not that was clearly stated in writing, or clearly explained, is a matter of conjecture at this point. The lesson here is to always get agreements in writing, especially if they are modifications to standard agreements.
According to Forbes.com, San Francisco is one of the markets most likely to recover quickly from the current real estate recession. In a nutshell, commercial real estate experts think that San Francisco’s strategic access to Asian trade (via the ports of San Francisco, and more importantly Oakland), and relatively strong office and apartment rental markets make it a good bet to recover fast. The logic is that a strong job base and relative lack of overbuilding in the commercial market means the economy will be strong, which will filter to the residential housing market.
Okay, we’ll take it. Good news is not that easy to find right now, so beggars can’t be choosers!
It looks like a lot more than candy-seeking children were spooked in October. With the wild, turbulent ride on Wall St and the Fed buying bank stocks and short term paper to avert disaster, October saw a lot of home buyers get spooked as well. In the Pleasanton real estate market, activity was down across all sectors of the market, and things got down right scary for a while as many of us saw our investments and 401k accounts take a major haircut. And political uncertainty added to the mix, as fear pretty much trumped everything. The good news? Things started to stabilize towards the end of the month, and the stock market actually bounced back. Thank god, because I was beginning to think hard about selling everything and stuffing the money in my mattress, or buying one of those lots that Eric Estrada is always pitching on late night TV. But bounce back the market did, and with it there seemed to be at least some stabilization, along with millions of simultaneous sighs of relief. And now that the election is past, we can hopefully get back to the job of getting our economy and the real estate market back on track. After all, I seem to remember hearing Obama saying that he is going to end war, eliminate hunger, fix our economy, give everyone free health care, and provide a good retirement for everyone. Heck, I’d settle for fixing the economy.
In Pleasanton, there were 30 pending sales in October, down from a strong 55 pending sales in September. Actually, that is not bad considering the climate of fear that prevailed throughout much of the month. But there is also a growing sense among some of the smart money that we may be closer to the bottom of the real estate market then many people think. And there are some great buys out there. Inventory overall dropped slightly, with 231 single family homes on the market at the end of October, as compared with 236 homes on the market at the end of September. (Click on the graph to enlarge)
In the under $1 million market segment, activity was down strongly. There were 21 pending sales in October, as compared with 37 pending sales in September. Inventory remained roughly the same with 122 single family homes on the market. (click on graph to enlarge)
In the $1 million to $2 million market segment, sales dropped from 15 pending sales in September to 7 in October. No doubt the gyrations in the financial markets had an impact on some buyer’s down payment funds. Inventory remained steady at 78 homes on the market, or a 10 month supply. (Click on the graph to enlarge)
In the luxury home segment over $2 million, there were 2 pending sales in October, as compared to 3 in September. Inventory dropped in this price segment to 31 homes on the market at the end of October, as compared to 37 at the end of September. Certainly some of the sellers decided that this was not the market they wanted to play in, and opted to wait for a better market to sell. Still, there is a 10 month supply of homes in this price segment, and it continues to struggle along. (Click on graph to enlarge)
Hopefully with the election, we can turn the page and get on with the recovery. Opportunity is certainly out there, and smart buyers with stable jobs, good credit, and strong assets are finding the market to be ripe with good values.
Timing financial markets, including the real estate market, is always tricky business. There are dozens of variables that have direct influence over the real estate market, including interest rates, buyer demand, population growth, economic factors, inventory levels, new home construction, changes in personal income, and job growth to name a few. It is the interplay of these variables that determine the strength of “the market” and determine price trends. Right now, there has been a lot of turmoil and volatility in the financial markets, as well as negative news about the real estate market both nationally and regionally. This has contributed to the downward pressure on the local real estate market.
I hear a lot of buyers say “I’m going to wait for the market to bottom out before I buy”. As a result, there is tremendous pent up-demand for housing in our area. All we need is for some definitive news that we have hit “the bottom” and there will be strong activity in the market. But finding “the bottom” is often harder than it seems. Unfortunately, there is no magic formula to alert us when we have hit “the bottom”. At that point, we are wondering “Is this the true bottom, or is it just a pause in the downward trend?”. The only way to know will be to wait and see, and if the market did in fact hit the bottom, and starts to trend up you will have missed it. In fact, the only way to know that you have hit “the bottom” is when you are well into the recovery.
Take a look at the above illustration. Everyone wants to buy at point “B”, which is the bottom. But actually buying there is more of a matter of luck than anything else, since at that point in time the market still seems to be going down. The reality is that most buyers who are waiting for “the bottom” end up buying at point “C”, which is well past the bottom. At this point, there are clear indications that the bottom has been hit. But due to pent-up demand from all the other buyers waiting for “the bottom”, the market has actually rebounded a little and is starting to trend up. In reality, you are better off buying at point “A” than point “C”, even though prices are still coming down. Why? Because if you buy at point “A”, you have several advantages:
* You have little or no competition for the house you want. Thus, you are in a better position to get a better price.
* You have the luxury of choice, and can find a home in a prime neighborhood that in normal market conditions would sell immediately, perhaps before you even had a chance to view it.
* Depending on the situation, you have less pressure to rush through inspections and gloss over potential issues with the property. You will have time to evaluate the condition and address any concerns you have. And the seller is much more likely to accommodate you if any property issues need correction.
If you buy at point “C”, you have missed the market. At that point, you are in a weaker position because:
* You have competition from other buyers who were waiting for “the bottom”. You will likely pay more for the house because of it.
* You have less choice in available homes as the market heats up. And prime properties in the best neighborhoods will sell quickly, sometimes with multiple offers
* You will be more inclined to make concessions on the condition of the home, as you will be under pressure from other potential buyers
* The seller also knows that we have hit “the bottom”, and is expecting prices to rise. This will raise their expectations, as well as the price they are willing to now accept
The fact is Real Estate is a long term proposition. If you are planning on staying in your house for 5 years or so, it is not crucial that you find the bottom of the market. I purchased my last 2 homes at the “top” of the market each time (in June of 1989, and July of 2000). And both houses have at least doubled in value, even if they declined in value after I purchased them. If you are a believer in market timing, I overpaid for both houses. And it is the best thing I ever did. In the long run, local real estate is very desirable, and given the long term growth in area population, job growth, and future restrictions on housing development, real estate will be in demand. So if you want to buy a home or move up into a larger home, now is a great time to do so, even if prices are still trending downward. Do it now before we hit “the bottom”, and you will be better off in the long run.
Despite the doom and gloom from Wall Street and the national real estate and mortgage markets that has permeated our collective psyche, the Pleasanton real estate market continues to be steady in the face of adversity. September saw pending sales increase to the second highest level of the year, with 55 pending sales, up from 50 in August. This is second only to April, which saw 67 pending sales. Inventory edged lower as well, with 236 single family homes on the market at the end of September, down from 264 at the end of August. (click on graph to enlarge)
So what accounts for this strong showing in the face of negative news? In my opinion, it is several factors
* Pleasanton remains a highly desirable community, with excellent schools, good commute access, strong job base, outstanding quality of life, clean, well manicured neighborhoods, and a charming downtown.
* We are still seeing a fairly consistent migration from the South Bay/Fremont to this area. Buyers are looking for good schools and safe neighborhoods
* The market here is more stable than many others in the outlying areas. Pleasanton has yet to be inundated with large increases in distressed properties for sale.
* Home values are attractive. While the market is certainly more stable than other areas of the East Bay, prices here have definitely dropped over the course of the last 2 years, and this creates opportunities for buyers to get homes in prime neighborhoods at great prices.
Inventory is down because some sellers have decided they don’t want to participate in the current market environment, where demanding buyers are extremely cautious and looking for prices that reflect the current reality. There is no getting around it… buyers demand value today, or they are just as happy to wait. But when a home is a great value, there is interest from buyers. And the more motivated sellers are willing to swallow hard and sell their homes at a price that is attractive to buyers.
The under $1 million market saw a sharp decrease in inventory, with 121 single family homes on the market at the end of September, down from 148 at the end of August. Pending sales were about the same, with 37 pending sales in September, down from 38 in August. (click on graph to enlarge)
The $1 million to $2 million market saw an increase in pending sales, with 15 pending sales in September, up from 9 pending sales in August. Inventory edged down to 78 single family homes on the market at the end of September, as compared with 83 in at the end of August. (click on graph to enlarge)
In the luxury home segment, inventory edged up, with 37 homes on the market at the end of September, as opposed to 33 at the end of August. Pending sales were basically flat, with 3 pending sales in September. (click on graph to enlarge)
Here’s hoping we can see some stabilization in the financial sector soon so we can see better days ahead.
Let’s see. I am beginning to feel like Bill Murray in the movie “Groundhog Day”. Alarm goes off, I get out of bed, and the everything looks eerily similar. For the Pleasanton CA real estate market, the month of June looked a lot like the month of May. Sales were steady but not spectacular, the economic and national real estate news was troubling, and an air of uncertainty hung over the real estate market like…. well like smoke from dozens of wild fires. Wait, that was smoke from dozens of wild fires.
It’s not that all of the news is bad. There are some mixed signals in the market, or at least the real estate market. As long as you don’t have your life savings invested in GM stock, things are doing pretty well, all things considered. We continue to see signs that some of the depressed markets in outlying areas are turning the corner, with sales activity up substantially in the previously decimated markets of Brentwood, Tracy, Antioch, and Stockton for example. And the continued sluggish market is creating some excellent deals on homes that would have had multiple offers back when Howie Mandell actually had hair.
For all of Pleasanton in June, the inventory of available single family homes ended the month at 243, which is actually down slightly from 245 at the end of May. Pending sales for the month of June were 49, down slightly from 53 pending sales in May. Basically a 5 month supply of homes on the market given the sales rate in June, which is not great, but not bad. (click on graph to enlarge).
For the under $1 million price range in Pleasanton, inventory was down from May, with 120 available single family homes at the end of June (as compared with 132 at the end of May). Pending sales were up, with 32 sales in the month of June as compared with 30 in May. Some neighborhoods are moving more than others, and there is still an emphasis on value in the market, but if priced right, you can still sell your home quickly in this price range. (Click on graph to enlarge).
For the $1 million to $2 million market, inventory was up slightly, with 81 available homes at the end of June, compared with 71 at the end of May. Pending sales were down some in this bracket, with 14 sales in June as opposed to 20 in April and May. Financing has remained problematic in this price bracket, with delays and hyper-stringent underwriting making transactions difficult and fraying the nerves of all parties to the transaction. (Click on graph to enlarge).
In the luxury home segment over $2 million, things remained unchanged in June. There were 42 available homes on the market at the end of both May and June, and 3 pending sales in both months. Activity in this price segment remains sluggish, and there continues to be downward pressure on prices here. (Click on graph to enlarge)
As we enter the prime summer months, all eyes remain on the Fed, who is walking the tight rope between lowering rates and increasing liquidity to shore up the battered banking system on the one hand, and taking steps to shore up the dollar to fight runaway oil prices and inflation on the other hand. How this battle takes shape in the coming months will go a long way in determining the state of the real estate market towards year end. And just to further confuse the waters, it is an election year, so anything goes. One thing is for sure… we live in interesting times.
The Pleasanton CA real estate market slowed as expected in November. While the month of November started out reasonably well, the market stalled towards the end of the month thanks to Thanksgiving (recent studies have suggested that the tryptophan in Turkey not only makes you sleepy, but also slows a person’s desire to buy real estate). Overall, the market was slow but steady. Pending sales were down for the month, ending at 31 pending sales, down from 45 in October. Inventory is also trending down, with 176 single family homes on the market at the end of November, as compared to 199 available homes at the end of October. Again, from a seasonal perspective, this is not unusual, although last year at this time the market had a surge in sales in November, with 55 pending sales. (click on graph to enlarge)
For the low end of the Pleasanton market (under $1 million), sales declined from October, with 15 pending sales for the month of November, as compared to 26 at the end of October. This is certainly a slow sales pace for this price range. Inventory dipped slightly, with 95 homes on the market in Pleasanton under $1 million at the end of November, down from 99 at the end of October. (click on graph to enlarge)
For the mid range of the Pleasanton market (between $1 million and $2 million), sales were up, with 12 pending sales in November, up from 10 in October and 7 in September. Inventory trended down, with 51 available homes at the end of November in this price bracket, down from 64 at the end of October. (click on graph to enlarge)
The luxury segment of the Pleasanton market showed a drop in pending sales in November, with 4 pending sales for the month, down from a strong October showing of 9 pending sales. Inventory drifted down, with 30 available homes at the end of November, down from 36 at the end of October, and 42 at the end of September. Buyers looking for value are a strong driver for the recent activity in this price range. (Click on graph to enlarge)
Overall, the market is obviously slow, but not dead. While sales activity is down from the summer, inventory is also trending down, and that trend is likely to continue in December. The real question is what will next year bring, which is certainly a source of speculation in real estate circles. I expect the national and state wide gloom and doom regarding real estate to continue through the year, with increases in foreclosures and downward pressure on prices on a national level. A lot will depend on the strength of the economy. If the real estate slump tips our economy into recession, then things could deteriorate strongly. If the rest of the economy remains relatively healthy, then I expect the Pleasanton market to see a market very similar to this year, with erratic sales activity, longer market times, and a flat to slowly declining prices, with some neighborhoods and price ranges faring better than others. Again, the long term outlook for Pleasanton is certainly positive, with continued job growth and the migration of families from other areas looking for a highly desirable city with top rated schools.